The greatest closer of all-time left the mound at Yankee Stadium last night.
Finally.
Though I can easily be described as the exact opposite of a New York Yankees fan, I tip my cap to Mariano Rivera. Truly a gentleman, one heck of a pitcher, who quite possibly threw the most disgusting, disturbing and unhittable pitch we’ll ever see.
A baseball wasn’t meant to do that, as many have said, but the fact that Rivera threw that cutter for nearly 20 years with such consistency and success is what is most astounding. Rivera is without question the greatest closer in baseball history – both in the regular season and the post-season. And you can certainly tip your cap to Rivera for coming back after blowing out his knee last year. He wouldn’t let it end that way, and returned to save 44 games this season.
It’s remarkable, it’s a great story and Rivera a great player.
But…
About this farewell tour, one that, frankly, was wildly mishandled and represents just another chapter of our sad downturn into hero worship. It represents the media’s massive stranglehold on our society and how said hero worship says more about us because we let it happen than it does about the players who seem to pull the “no, stop it, well, OK, tell me how much you love me” act.
Lost in the sentimentality of last night, the gushing Twitter hashtags, the overarching media slobber fest, the genuinely great moment when Derek Jeter and Andy Pettitte came to take him off the mound, the tears, the emotion, was the fact that this wonderful moment had already been overdone and overblown before it even actually happened.
When Rivera announced this would be his last year, you probably could have predicted this would happen. Endless stories, standing ovations, tributes in every city for the last six weeks of the season. I don’t so much blame Rivera – we did this mostly ourselves. But Mo was a party to it, never said to stop, and soaked it all in.
It was a obvious he enjoyed it – and who wouldn’t? An entire year of everyone, including your arch rivals, showing you the love? It’s the ultimate ego trip.
Yet I remain wildly disappointed in us for the whole charade. What happened to us? Why is it a lead story that the underachieving and eliminated Yankees contemplating playing Rivera in centerfield against the hapless Astros this weekend? What about the exciting playoff races still happening? What about the Pirates making the playoffs for the first time since 1992?
1992!
You know what a fun, feel-good, easy story to write about that is? But baseball was overshadowed by Rivera’s farewell campaign. We’re a cult of personality, for sure.
And I can’t help but note that Todd Helton, perhaps the best player in Colorado Rockies history, retired without much fanfare as well this season. The difference? He waited until almost the very end of the season to do it. They held a modest ceremony and gave him a horse.
I texted a friend: “Why is Helton getting a horse?”
His response: “No idea. Maybe some connection to his Tennessee roots? Maybe he has a horse farm? We’ll never know because it might interfere with the great Rivera Farewell Tour.”
And he’s right. I’d never argue that Todd Helton reached Rivera’s level of performance or had the same impact on the game. And I get it – Rivera being one of the most recognizable Yankees is a lot different that Helton being the most recognizable Rockies.
But my goodness, this year has been nearly all Mo all the time. Goosebumps at the All-Star game, standing ovations, farewell ceremonies the last month in several cities. Campaigns demanding you recognize him as a hero, talk radio conversations about why he is or is not worthy of hero status. Stories about his legend growing each day, about him never sharing his true secret to the cutter, but helping other pitchers with the finer points. Practically every major paper and magazine in the country ran a story about it.
ESPN has a “Follow the Farewell” sub-page. AT&T allowed you to send him goodbye messages. The San Diego Padres gave him and his family beach bikes. Rivera barely pitched against the Padres during his career, or at Petco Park.
Good grief.
A little much, is it not? In a world of snark and constant criticism, I must stand apparently alone in my belief we’re gone overboard on the Mo Mania. Searching Google for a solid 15 minutes did not yield many results that showed any – even remote – criticism of Rivera’s farewell tour. In fact, one of the few a I found was from a newspaper…in Ottawa, Canada.
So perhaps this is falling on the angry deaf ears of folks who see nothing wrong with it. Perhaps I’m just a very old soul trapped in a still somewhat young man’s body. I just find the whole thing to be missing a shade of tact and a smidge of humility.
That’s not all on Rivera, either. We do this hero worship thing quite well. Yet Mo still did the 650 interviews and 400 posed pictures (all estimates) for TV, radio, newspapers, web sites and magazines. You can’t blame the guy completely for enjoying it a little bit, or a lot.
But I think I would have respected it more had Rivera pulled a Billy Chapel and just signed a ball telling them he was done. No fanfare, no big production, just riding off into the sunset and moving on.
Instead, the year-long goodbye left Thursday as somewhat anti-climatic. And you run the risk of it becoming a joke, which while Rivera seemed to avoid, others have not. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar got blasted for his retirement tour in 1989, Brett Favre and Michael Jordan mocked slightly – but mainly because they came out of retirement.
Sadly, MLB Commissioner Bud Selig announced over a year in advance – much like NBA Commissioner David Stern – that he would be leaving. Are they expecting the same – or even half – the farewell?
George Strait is doing it in country music, like so many musicians and bands before him. I mean, I get it, you want to give people a chance to say thanks for the talent and entertainment, but after a while, the novelty wears off and you’re just staring at someone who appears like they don’t really want to leave the stage, like they just want to hear the really, really loud cheers and feel that emotion.
Which makes it actually less so. The longer we have to say goodbye, the easier it becomes.
Let me repeat, I respect Rivera’s career, his impact on the game and what he did off the field, as well. But this…well…aren’t we just a tad embarrassed? Maybe, for once, life should imitate art. Even a somewhat hokey baseball movie disguised as a romantic comedy from 1999 got it right.
Please, fellas, from now on, just tell them you’re through.
For Love of the Game.








