Sometimes, things just happen and it’s no one’s fault.
While we can blame certain people for certain things – like, say, Charlie Sheen for brining “warlock” and “tiger blood” into the American lexicon – it’s not quite so easy to place responsibility at any one person’s feet.
It’s important to remember this when the topic turns to Texas Rangers star outfielder and 2010 MVP Josh Hamilton’s recent injury.
In the first inning of the Rangers Tuesday game against the Detroit Tigers, Rangers third base coach Dave Anderson told Hamilton no one was covering home on a foul-ball pop-up that both the Tigers third baseman Brandon Inge and catcher Victor Martinez moved over to catch.
Detroit pitcher Brad Penny just stood on the mound – never really even moving towards home. That left the base wide open.
Anderson repeated the fact twice. Suddenly, Hamilton tagged up and began making the 90-foot journey to home – which prompted Martinez, who was about 50 feet away, to break towards home as well.
As you might guess, the guy with the 40-foot head start got there first.
Hamilton went in all Pete Rose-ish (headfirst) and Martinez applied the tag.
And then Hamilton felt a bit of pain. Turns out, he had a small fracture develop in the humerus bone in his upper arm because of the play.
Now, Hamilton’s on the shelf for six to eight weeks. He can’t touch a bat for a month.
Then Hamilton went all crazy ex-girlfriend on Anderson after the game, calling the play “stupid” and “dumb” in the past few days and in not so many words, blaming Anderson for his injury.
He also kinda, sorta implied that he was an innocent bystander just doing his job by listening to his coach.
“I listened to my third-base coach,” Hamilton said at the time. “That’s a little too aggressive. The whole time I was watching the play I was listening. [He said] ‘Nobody’s at home, nobody’s at home.’ I was like, ‘Dude, I don’t want to do this. Something’s going to happen.’ But I listened to my coach. And how do you avoid a tag the best? By going in headfirst and get out of the way and get in there. That’s what I did.”
Come on, Josh. That’s comical in and of itself.
We all know that no one is the pros really listens to their coaches.
Apparently Hamilton is clairvoyant. He just knew that something was going to happen.
Well, if you feel that strongly about something, if you just know you’re going to get hurt, then don’t run.
And maybe don’t go in head first.
How quickly Hamilton forgets that last year he scored from second base on an infield hit. As ESPN’s Tim Kurkjian pointed out, Hamilton called it his proudest moment at the time.
Anderson referenced that as well yesterday.
“You think about in the past what we’ve done,” he said. “He’s scored from second on a groundout to the infield twice. He’s scored from first on a long single. We’ve done double steals with him. That’s a part of our game is being aggressive and taking advantage of situations. The unfortunate part is that he got hurt. But if you go out and play the game and play hard, those things are going to happen.”
So if you are Josh Hamilton, what you can do is show two sides of a coin: you’re either aggressive and hungry enough to want to score on weird plays like that, or you’re more of the cautious type. But you can’t be both.
This whole saga got blown a little out of proportion on Wednesday, with sports radio dials everywhere dissecting the play 30 different ways.
Headfirst or feet first? Was it important to even try in the first inning of a game in mid-April? Was it Anderson’s fault because he kept repeating it like he wanted Hamilton to go? Was Hamilton just a good soldier? What does this say about the future of baseball, in youth ball or the pros – will players start thinking more for themselves on the basepaths?
Seriously, fellas? I know it’s a little slow these days – NFL lockout dragging on, NBA playoffs not yet started, no real attention grabbing headlines – but to spend nearly two hours of your show on subplots in this one play that really don’t exist is a bit much, even for a guy like me.
I shudder to think what the current media would have done with Roger Dorn when he was told to get out there and take one for the team in “Major League II.” We would have heard Dorn was a company line-toeing stooge, or that Jake Taylor’s old-school ways had gone too far this time.
We ruin so many moments in sports and life by over analyzing them.
Just let it be.
Hamilton tried to score – and if he would have, people would be talking about what an amazing, gutsy, heads-up play he made. That plays like that are the difference between great and good.
So he got hurt, so what? Yes, he’s out six-to-eight weeks. Yes, he can’t even swing a bat until mid-May. But let’s look at Hamilton’s track record for injuries:
April 2011 Fractured arm
Sept. 2010 Fractured ribs
June 2010 Hamstring tightness
May 2010 Knee
Sept. 2009 Pinched nerve (neck)
June 2009 Torn abdominal muscle
April 2009 Strained ribs
Face it, the guy was going to miss some games at some point. Since getting into the majors full-time in 2007, Hamilton has played in 133 games or more only once in a season (2008).
“I can understand that if I was pulling things like hamstrings or quads and it was not actual high-intensity things like hitting walls,” Hamilton said. “I’m making plays that the game calls me to make and I’m getting injured that way. That proves to me that I can get hurt anytime doing anything. I’m tired of talking about it, to be honest with you.”
But he said he wouldn’t change the way he plays.
“How else would I play?” Hamilton said. “You can get hurt by doing anything.”
Bingo, kid. Them’s the breaks, as they used to say.
It took him a few days, but at least he understands what most of us already did. You can’t prevent the Sports Gods bringing the pain. Ricky Henderson once got frostbite from falling asleep with an ice bag on. People fall down stairs, throw out their backs bending over to pick up their kids’ toys.
Um, how shall we say, “stuff” happens.
Thankfully, Hamilton did apologize to Anderson publically and privately yesterday.
“I let my emotions get ahead of thinking things through,” Hamilton said. “The more I think about it, the more I understand that I take responsibility for what happened because I had the choice not to go or the choice to go. I just appreciate Dave having confidence in my ability to think I could make that play.”
Hamilton also added, “The object is to score and if you go feet first, that gives them all this up here to tag. It is what it is. It’s over. It sucks it happened, but it happened. We’ll deal with it.”
Exactly.
And hopefully you’ll deal with it better next time.

